Jump to content

Providing independent coverage of the Minnesota Vikings.
Subscribe to Vikings Journal Email

The Forums

Article: NFL Changes the PAT--Affecting Game Strategy and...

NFL Football Talk Today, 10:57 PM
The days of heading into the kitchen for another beverage (or somewhere else in the house) during routine extra points in NFL games are o...
Full topic ›

Moss Shows Up At Pelican Rapids' Graduation

Minnesota Vikings Talk Today, 10:57 PM
This is one of the coolest stories I've seen. Former Vikings star Randy Moss showed up at the Pelican Rapids High School graduation tonig...
Full topic ›

What is Adrian Peterson's receiving potential with Te...

Minnesota Vikings Talk Today, 10:31 PM
This is a topic I haven't seen raised anywhere.  AP is widely thought of as the best runner in the game, but as a poor receiver....
Full topic ›

The Dirtiest Team In The League Does It Again: Patriots A...

NFL Football Talk Today, 05:18 PM
http://www.nydailyne...ticle-1.2083559       FOXBOROUGH — Another playoff win for the Patriots, another allegation of wro...
Full topic ›

Article: Vikings Post-Draft Depth Chart - LINEBACKERS

Minnesota Vikings Talk Today, 05:18 PM
Minnesota Vikings rookie mini camp has concluded and the coaches have gotten their first look at some of their new players on the footbal...
Full topic ›

Rule Changes

NFL Football Talk Today, 02:41 PM
Just some links on this:  NFL proposed rule changes: winners and losers  What you need to know about the NFL’s 2015 rule change...
Full topic ›

From MinnCentric


Sacrificing Talent for Chemistry on the Offensive Line

If all goes according to plan, the Minnesota Vikings will enter the 2014 season with one of the best offensive lines in football and will have had the same five starters since Matt Kalil was drafted in 2012—a three-year stretch that is as valuable as it is rare. But don’t read too much into it.
Image courtesy of Bruce Kluckhohn-USA TODAY Sports
Despite spotty play at left guard, it seems that any potential replacement for Charlie Johnson is more a pipe dream than a reality for fans of a change. And that really is too bad.

While head coach Mike Zimmer has indicated that much of the reason that Johnson will keep his job is because fifth-round pick David Yankey’s potential growth as an NFL-quality guard was stunted by the quarter system at Stanford—one that kept him out of offseason training activities in May and June—there is a significant amount of push from the Zimmer camp to keep the line as-is because of the value of continuity.

This is a mistake.

There are two functions of offensive line play: pass protection and run blocking. In that context, there are multiple “top five” offensive lines, but broken into those two functions generally produce the following offensive lines by Pro Football Focus and Football Outsiders in 2013: Philadelphia, Cincinnati, Denver, Washington, Dallas and Green Bay.

In 2012, the same publications found the top lines to be San Francisco, New England, New York (Jets), New York (Giants), Denver, Cleveland, Buffalo and Detroit.

There’s very little transfer of quality from one year to the next in these measures, and it seems like Denver’s offensive line is the only one to appear in both lists. Some of this can be attributed to injury (New England’s line was injured in 2013 and Philadelphia’s was in 2012), but it seems like continuity of quality in general is difficult to achieve.

If looking at the top offensive lines in general solely by PFF grade in 2012 (San Francisco, New England, New York (Jets), Denver and Cleveland) one can measure their “continuity” along the line by their change in grade.

Two of those offensive lines (San Francisco and Cleveland) didn’t change their lineup on the offensive line, but didn’t repeat as a top offensive line, per PFF. New England replaced one player and did not repeat. The Jets replaced two players and didn’t repeat. Denver replaced two players and moved one from guard to center and found themselves in the top five again.

The two teams that didn’t change at all moved from first to ninth and from fifth to twelfth. The team with one change moved from second to fourteenth. The Jets dropped from third to 27th. Only the Broncos stayed where they were, going from fourth to third.

Much of that has to do with Peyton Manning, but their aggressive commitment to improvement along the line was certainly one of the reasons. The same results hold from 2011 to 2012 (New England was the only team to stay in the top five and did so by losing two players and moving a third) or from 2010 to 2011—where Houston and New England retained their top-five status and retained six of their ten offensive linemen in their original positions.

Minnesota has reasons to be proud of keeping the same five starters for three consecutive years, but it’s a mistake to confuse that for having a top-tier offensive line for three consecutive years. An aggressive commitment to improvement would discard the value of that “chemistry” in order to put the most talent in the position as possible.

This is the same chemistry that saw Matt Kalil give up two more sacks, eight more hits and fourteen more hurries in his second year on one side of Johnson and John Sullivan give up three more sacks and three more quarterback hurries on the other side. Charlie Johnson himself has ranked 34th and 39th in combined allowed sacks, hits and hurries per pass protecting snap (of around 55 qualifying guards) in the past two years and performing as an even worse run blocker.

That doesn’t mean forcing Yankey into a spot he’s not ready to play. If there are in fact technique issues that he has to overcome, then he should be held back in favor of the superior option (though, of note, this did not stop the Vikings from starting a younger and less technically refined Brandon Fusco over Geoff Schwartz).

But if continuity is an overriding reason to start a quantity known to be bad without much chance at improvement (at age 30, Johnson’s ceiling is pretty much maxed out) over an unknown but likely positive quantity—the fourth ranked interior linemen by most scouting services—then the Vikings should reconsider their approach.


  • Share:
  • submit to reddit
Subscribe to Vikings Journal Email

2 Comments

mike wants wins
Aug 13 2014 08:14 AM
Agree, 100 percent
TheLeviathan
Aug 13 2014 03:15 PM

I'm a huge Yankey fan...so I'm with you.  He might have been my favorite pick of last season's draft.


Similar Articles


by Aj Mansour , Yesterday, 01:30 PM


by Arif Hasan , Yesterday, 03:27 AM


by Arif Hasan , 19 May 2015


by Bo Mitchell , 16 May 2015


by Joe Oberle , 07 May 2015